Every skeleton in the ancient hominin cave is female
For a decade, the Rising Star cave system in South Africa has been yielding Homo naledi bones, nearly two dozen skeletons of a small-brained, two-legged relative of ours that lived around 300,000 years ago.
Nobody had been able to determine their sex. Now a team has used proteomics, reading ancient proteins preserved in dental enamel long after DNA would have degraded, to analyze 20 teeth from the skeletons [17]. Every single one is female. That includes Neo and DH1, the two most complete skeletons, both assumed for years to be male. The gene variant AMELY, found only in biological males, was simply absent from every sample [17]. There are no known human cemeteries anywhere on Earth, and no collections of ancient nonhuman primate bones, that consist entirely of one sex. The Rising Star team has argued for years that Homo naledi intentionally buried its dead, an unexpected behavior in a hominin with a brain roughly the size of an orange. If the new proteomic data holds up, the implication is stranger still: that these small-brained relatives of ours may have practiced sex-specific mortuary rituals.
What each field noticed (1)
A weird result from an already weird hominin
This is a primary research story, just published in Cell, and Live Science treated it exactly that way [17]. The technique matters: proteomics can sequence ancient proteins that survive longer than ancient DNA, which is why this was possible at all. The study's authors are careful with their language. "Weird" is Lee Berger's own word. The most plausible explanation, as paleoanthropologist John Hawks writes, is "cultural selection after death by sex," which would make Homo naledi the earliest known practitioner of sex-specific burial [17]. That is a claim nobody fully believes yet, which is exactly what makes it worth watching.
Read the story





