The Field Guide · No. 04
"Cuts your risk 50%" vs. what actually changes
A "50% risk cut" is relative; the absolute change can be tiny, so always ask what the risk went from and to in real numbers.
"New drug cuts your risk of a heart attack in half" sounds enormous. But cut in half from what? If your risk drops from 2 in 100 to 1 in 100, that is technically a 50% reduction, and it is also a change of just one person in a hundred. Both numbers are true. One is designed to impress you, and one tells you what actually changed.
The impressive-sounding one is the relative risk. It compares the two groups as a ratio, so a drop from 2% to 1% becomes "50% lower." The plain one is the absolute risk, the actual difference in your chances, which here is one percentage point. Headlines and press releases almost always reach for the relative number, because bigger sounds better.
Neither number is a lie, but the relative number without the absolute number is missing the part you need. A 50% reduction of a large risk is a genuinely big deal. A 50% reduction of a tiny risk is often barely worth noticing. You cannot tell which one you are looking at unless you know the starting risk.
So whenever you see a percentage reduction, ask two questions the headline usually skips: from what, and to what, in real numbers? "From 2 in 100 to 1 in 100" tells you far more than "cuts risk 50%." Once you start asking for the absolute numbers, a lot of scary and a lot of miraculous headlines shrink back to their true size.
What to remember
- Relative risk is a ratio ("50% lower") and usually sounds bigger than the real change.
- Absolute risk is the actual change in your chances (for example, 2 in 100 down to 1 in 100).
- Always ask "from what, to what?" in real numbers before reacting to a percentage.
From the record
The relative risk (RR) of a bad outcome in a group given intervention is a proportional measure estimating the size of the effect of a treatment compared with other interventions or no treatment at all.
Asked often
Is a "50% risk reduction" a lie?
No, it is usually a true relative figure. But without the starting risk it is misleading. Halving a 2% risk gives a 1 percentage point drop, while halving a 40% risk gives a 20 point drop. Same 50%, very different reality.
Which number should I trust more?
Look for the absolute risk, the real change in your chances stated as actual numbers. It is the most useful figure for deciding whether a treatment is worth it for you.
Read the news better, every morning.
We send you the day's real progress in science, medicine and beyond, told plainly and sourced. Free, forever.
Free forever, no spam. One click to unsubscribe, and we never sell your email.